MCAT Critical Analysis and Reasoning Skills Question 33: Answer and Explanation

Home > MCAT Test > MCAT critical analysis and reasoning skills practice tests

Test Information

Question: 33

6. Which of the following is NOT included as evidence of innumeracy among doctors?

  • A. Personal experience in the form of an anecdote
  • B. Statistics regarding the frequency of death due to heart disease
  • C. Recent academic research
  • D. A humorous exaggeration of a common experience

Correct Answer: B

Explanation:

B This is a Retrieval/EXCEPT question.

A: No. The author describes a conversation he had with a doctor, which qualifies as a personal anecdote.

B: Yes. The correct answer will contain a statement that is NOT given as an example of innumeracy among doctors. Death due to heart and circulatory disease is mentioned in paragraph 4 as an example of the tendency to "equate the risk from obscure and exotic malady" with the chances of acquiring a common disease. There is no connection made here to risk assessments made by doctors.

C: No. The "recent study" referenced in paragraph 7 is given as an example of doctors' inaccurate risk assessments.

D: No. The author speculates that in order to avoid being idle, doctors seek to have at least eleven people in the waiting room. The author intends this as a humorous exaggeration of the common experience of waiting in a doctor's office-the last sentence of the passage links the example to the issue of innumeracy.

Previous       Next